Can I Change My Asylum Lawyer in the Middle of the Process?

Asylum Lawyer

Navigating the asylum process can be daunting, often requiring the expertise and guidance of an experienced asylum lawyer. However, what happens if you find yourself questioning whether your current legal representation is the right fit for your case? Can you change your asylum lawyer during the process? 


This article delves into the complexities of this issue, offering insights into the importance of legal representation in asylum cases, understanding the possibility of changing lawyers, steps involved in making such a change, potential challenges, and seeking necessary guidance and support.


Understanding the Importance of Legal Representation in Asylum Cases

Seeking asylum involves intricate legal proceedings where having competent legal counsel is crucial. Asylum lawyers play a pivotal role in advocating for the rights of individuals fleeing persecution and seeking refuge in a new country.


The Significance of Competent Legal Counsel in Asylum Cases

Competent legal representation can significantly impact the outcome of an asylum case. Lawyers with expertise in asylum law understand the intricacies of the process, ensuring that you are properly prepared and that your case is presented effectively to immigration authorities.


This time in your life is already stressful and challenging, so trying to push through the application process without an asylum attorney adds additional strain. Your asylum immigration lawyer can also make sure that every step of the process is completed perfectly to avoid delays and further frustration.


Roles and Responsibilities of Asylum Lawyer

An asylum lawyer’s responsibilities include assessing the validity of an asylum claim, preparing and filing necessary documentation, representing you in hearings, and advocating for your rights throughout the process.


Specific things your immigration asylum lawyer can do include:


  • Assessing your initial eligibility for sanctuary.
  • Develop a strategy to build your case.
  • Help you file Form I-589 and pay the fee if necessary.
  • Advice on what evidence and documentation to file with Form I-589.
  • Provide guidance and coaching for your asylum interview.
  • Be present as a legal representative at your interview.
  • Assist with any denial procedures.
  • Help you apply for LPR (Legal Permanent Residency – Green Card).


As you can see, their services are potentially invaluable during this important time in your life. This is why it’s imperative to choose the right political asylum attorney and understand the possibility of changing representation if you aren’t satisfied with the service.

Potential Reasons for Considering a Change in Legal Representation

Asylum Immigration Lawyer

Despite the critical role of political asylum lawyers, there may be instances where applicants consider changing their legal representation. Reasons for this may include communication issues, lack of confidence in the lawyer’s abilities, or changes in personal circumstances. To give a summary:


  • Inability to pay for legal representation.
  • Dissatisfaction with your progress.
  • A lack of confidence in the services provided.
  • A lack of transparency during the process.
  • Changes in your circumstances.


Can I Change My Asylum Lawyer?


The question of whether you can change your asylum lawyer mid-process is a common one among asylum seekers. The answer is yes, it is possible to change lawyers, but it’s essential to consider the legal implications and potential challenges associated with such a decision.

Legal Considerations and Implications


Changing asylum lawyers involves legal considerations such as assessing any contractual obligations with the current lawyer, understanding the impact on the case timeline and strategy, and ensuring compliance with relevant immigration laws and regulations.

Ability to Fire Your Political Asylum Lawyer

You have the right to fire your asylum lawyer at any time

There is no legal precedent that prevents you from changing your legal counsel. This is a personal thing, much in the same way that you can change your car or healthcare provider. 


However, you must be aware that if you have a contract with the representative, you will have to pay any outstanding fees outlined in the terms. This could be a cancellation fee, or perhaps the contract was for a minimum term. Trying to avoid settling your account with the lawyer could result in legal and criminal complications.


The Affect This Has on Your Application with the USCIS

Changing your asylum lawyer does not affect your application process

Whoever you decide to use shouldn’t impact the process or cause issues with any of the government agencies, such as the USCIS or consulate office. You have the right to use whatever legal counsel you wish. 


However, it is advisable to post a letter to the USCIS or the last immigration office you had contact with to inform them of the change. This makes sure that any future case developments and documentation are sent to your new asylum lawyer.


Factors to Consider Before Making a Decision

Before deciding to change lawyers, you should assess your reasons for dissatisfaction, evaluate the potential consequences of your case, and understand any contractual obligations with your current lawyer.


Assessing the reasons for dissatisfaction with current representation

You HAVE to be sure that your reasons for dismissal are valid and that you are making the right decision. Remember that even the best asylum lawyer in USA does not have full control over the application process. 

Oftentimes, what seems like a lawyer error is more likely an issue with the USCIS and its slow processing times. This cannot be improved regardless of your legal counsel.

Evaluating the impact of a change on the asylum case timeline and strategy

As mentioned above, changing your immigration lawyer asylum representation shouldn’t have any bearing on the progress of your case. However, it can cause delays if you don’t notify the relevant government agencies of the change.

For example, if you don’t notify the USCIS, they will send important information to your old attorney. As a result, you may never be aware of important developments.

Understanding any contractual obligations with the current lawyer

As stated above, oftentimes you have a contract with your attorney. This includes things like terms of service, and what happens in the event of contract termination. Make sure you fully understand the implications of firing your asylum lawyer and are clear on any remaining fees you must pay.

Political Asylum Lawyer

Steps to Changing Asylum Lawyers Mid-Process

The actual process to change representation is straightforward with three main steps:


  1. Notify your current attorney of the termination.
  2. Notify relevant government authorities.
  3. Coordinate the transfer of case documents.

Notification and Termination of the Current Lawyer-Client Relationship

You should formally notify your current lawyer of your decision to terminate the representation and request the transfer of case documents. Make sure this is done in writing so you have proof of the request. We also advise making a copy of the requested document for your records.


Researching and Selecting a New Asylum Lawyer

Thorough research should be conducted to identify a new asylum lawyer with expertise in asylum law and a track record of success in similar cases. Always check social proofs such as testimonials and previous client reviews. Where possible, see if it’s possible to speak to previous clients so you can understand more about the new lawyer.


Informing Relevant Authorities and Agencies About the Change in Representation

You should inform relevant authorities, such as immigration courts or asylum offices, about the change in legal representation to ensure seamless transition and continuity in the case proceedings. This makes sure that any new documents and case information are sent to your new asylum lawyer.


Coordinating the Transfer of Case Documents and Information Between Lawyers

Efficient coordination between the old and new legal representatives is crucial to ensure the smooth transfer of case documents and information, minimizing disruptions in the asylum process.


Remember that your case file is your property, not the lawyers

This means that you have the right to get it transferred to your new attorney. The ABA (American Bar Association) states in its Model Rules that “when a client/attorney relationship is terminated, it’s the lawyer’s responsibility to protect the client’s interests, including by surrendering the client’s file and any property”.


Simply put, your old attorney must make sure your new asylum lawyer gets the case information. You still may have to chase for this to be done, though so always be proactive.


Potential Challenges and Considerations

Although you have a right to use whichever legal representative you please, you must be aware of the potential challenges and consequences which include possible delays, and financial difficulties.


Delays and Disruptions in the Asylum Process

Changing lawyers mid-process may result in delays and disruptions, potentially impacting the overall timeline of the asylum case. For example, you may not want to proceed with the following steps until you have agreed to your contract with a new asylum lawyer and your information has been transferred:


  • Completion of application forms
  • Gathering of relevant documentation
  • Filing of Form I-589
  • Attending the asylum interview


This is why it’s important to be 100% sure about your decision and think carefully about how it could affect your asylum clock.


Ensuring Seamless Communication Between New and Old Legal Representatives

Effective communication between the new and old legal representatives is essential to maintain continuity in the representation and avoid misunderstandings or errors. 


If you have selected a competent asylum lawyer as a replacement, they should be proactive and do whatever they can to maintain that communication and make sure they are up to date on your case with all the relevant files. However, we advise being proactive too and working with your new representative to make sure this is done quickly.

Managing any Financial Implications or Obligations

You should clarify any financial implications or obligations associated with changing lawyers and ensure that they are addressed appropriately.


Oftentimes, you pay a fixed flat rate for legal counsel from an asylum lawyer. This fee usually covers a set process or a specific number of hours. If the representative did not complete those hours or all the processes covered by the flat rate, you are entitled to ask for a refund.


If you feel a refund is due, and the attorney disputes this, ask them to provide a detailed breakdown of the work involved and/or a timesheet breakdown that shows the hours they put into your case. Failure to comply or a reluctance to hand over documents can occur. 


In these instances, remain polite, but ultimately, you should contact your state’s Bar Association and file a complaint. This usually causes action as it can put an attorney’s license and reputation at risk.

Best Asylum Lawyer In Usa

Seeking Guidance and Support

We understand that this process may seem difficult – after all, your asylum lawyer is meant to be the person you go to for support. So, who do you turn to when that person is failing you? Luckily, there is a range of support groups and advocacy groups that you can contact.


Consulting With Trusted Sources for Advice and Assistance

Seeking advice from trusted sources, such as legal experts or immigrant advocacy groups, can provide valuable guidance and support in navigating the process of changing asylum lawyers. Some well-known organizations and support groups include:


  • Immigration Advocates Network – Link
  • American Immigration Council – Link
  • Advocates for Immigrant Rights – Link
  • National Immigrant Justice Center – Link

Utilizing Resources Provided by Legal Aid Organizations

Legal aid organizations often offer resources and assistance to individuals seeking asylum, including guidance on changing legal representation. Indeed, there are organizations like Restoration Immigration Legal Aid that can source pro bono immigration legal advice for situations like this.

Seeking Clarification From Immigration Authorities

If there are uncertainties or questions regarding the process of changing lawyers, applicants can seek clarification from immigration authorities or relevant legal entities. It is possible to contact your local USCIS branch, for example, for clarification, and to make sure they have the details of your new asylum lawyer for further case developments.



You Have the Right to Quality Legal Counsel

Changing asylum lawyers mid-process is indeed possible, but it requires careful consideration of legal implications, thorough research, and effective communication between all parties involved. 


By understanding the importance of legal representation, assessing reasons for dissatisfaction, and seeking necessary guidance and support, you can make informed decisions to ensure the best possible outcome for your asylum cases.


If you do decide to change asylum lawyers, it’s incredibly important that you are clear on the terms of your existing contract. This includes any outstanding fees. Also, make sure that the transfer of case files to your new asylum lawyer is done smoothly and within a short timeframe.



Can I change my asylum lawyer for any reason?

Changing asylum lawyers is possible, but it’s essential to assess the reasons for dissatisfaction and understand any potential limitations or implications associated with such a decision. You are under no legal obligation to continue working with a lawyer, but you may have to still pay for their services depending on the terms of your contract.


Will changing my lawyer affect my asylum case?

Changing lawyers should not impact the progress of your asylum case in any way from a legal perspective. However, it could cause delays. For example, you may have to delay filing Form I-589 until you have hired a new lawyer. Or, you may have to reschedule your asylum interview. There could also be delays in the transfer of your case files from one lawyer to another.


How do I find a new asylum lawyer?

Researching and selecting a new asylum lawyer with expertise in asylum law and a track record of success is crucial. Legal aid organizations and trusted sources can provide valuable assistance in this process. Make sure you do thorough background checks on the representative. Do they have relevant qualifications? What have past asylum seekers said about their reliability and services? Can you book an initial meeting/consultation with them?


What should I do if I’m unsure about changing my lawyer?

If uncertain about changing lawyers, seeking guidance and support from legal experts or immigrant advocacy groups can help clarify concerns and make informed decisions. Also, think carefully about the reasons why you wish to change. Make sure they are valid and that you are not mistaking delays caused by the USCIS for inaction from your lawyer.



More Posts

Schedule Your Legal Advice Now